Thursday, October 23, 2014


10/22/14                                         Darkness Too Visible Response

“Darkness too Visible” by Megan Cox Gurdon talks about young adult literature and it’s suitability towards teenagers. The author takes a strong stance on this debate, stating throughout the article that the books young adults are reading today are inappropriate for their age group. Overall, Megan Cox Gurdon heavily states her opinion on young adult books and their affects on teenagers.
              Megan Cox Gurdon uses different forms of craft to influence the readers in seeing her position. For example, she uses loaded words to turn “inappropriate” books into “harmful” books. She manipulates the readers to become more inclined to see the young adult books as negative for teens by describing them with larger vocabulary, such as changing words from “bad”, to “traumatic”. Additionally, Megan uses narrative from parent’s perspectives to offer first hand evidence to support her claim. Exhibited in the story of Amy Freeman, a 46 year old mother of three who leaves local bookstore Barnes and Nobles empty handed after finding the young adult books unsuitable for her teens. “Nothing, not a thing, I could imagine giving my daughter. It was all vampires and suicide and self-mutilation this dark, dark stuff.”

           After reading this article, it is evident that the author holds a very strong opinion towards young adult literature and if teens should be reading these books. In terms of my own personal opinion, I believe teenagers should be allowed to read and venture within these young adult books. I believe there is nothing in these books that kids aren’t already exposed to in their own lives and experiences. Megan Cox Gurdon may not have changed my position on this debate, however, she used many great craft tools that made me think about the other perspectives on this topic, and, what young adult literature could subliminally be doing to me.

Sunday, October 19, 2014

Troubling Themes Within "Thirteen Reasons Why"




         “Suicide- The act or an instance of taking one's own life voluntarily and intentionally especially by a person of years of discretion and of sound mind. The individual is in control of their fate.”
In suicide, it is often thought, as this definition says, that the person who is considering taking their own life has the power to give up or go through with their plan. Others around them have no influence in their decision when the moment actually comes. But for Hannah Baker in “Thirteen Reasons Why” the decision to kill herself was correlated far beyond her inner emotions. CloseStyle: MLA APA Chicago

Top of Form

The story, “Thirteen Reasons Why” by Jay Asher introduces and elaborates on many topics that are troubling to read. Through the main character, Hannah Baker, the author illustrates the ongoing struggles of depression and suicide that the book deals with. The author depicts this best through quotes in the tapes that Hannah has left behind for certain individuals to discover after she has taken her own life. Hannah sends out 13 tapes to people who were involved in her suicide, and it is in these tapes that the quotes riddled with trouble and confusion are most present. Through the point of view of Clay, a boy who received a tape, we are exposed into the Hannah’s world and what was going through her mind when she thought about killing herself. We are given a point of view on how characters like Clay and others who’ve received the tapes are dealing with the grief and guilt that comes through these messages. Overall, there are many things troubling to read within “Thirteen Reasons Why”, and the author shows this most through quotes of Hannah Baker.

            Jay Asher shows Hannah’s sorrows and depression, and therefore most troubling moments, through quotes. To start off, in the beginning of the story, we are introduced to Hannah’s life at home. She talks about how she began to feel unsafe even in her own home. “We all know the sound a camera makes when it snaps a picture. Even some of the digitals do it for nostalgias sake. And I always keep my window open, about an inch or two, to let in fresh air. Which is how I knew someone was standing outside.” Without even thinking deeper about this quote it is obvious to why this scene is very troubling. The idea of the main character being stalked within her own home is very creepy and scary to read, but this becomes even more troubling when figuring out there is a correlation between this moment and Hannah’s suicide. This quote allows readers to be connected to the main character in seeing her in her most vulnerable state of mind through her first hand quotes. The author uses quotes as a technique to better establish the main character’s interior and exterior troubles.

            Additionally, towards the middle of the story, we learn about Hannah’s biggest fears and insecurities through quotes the author provides. At this part of the story, Hannah is sharing a traumatic experience she underwent after a regular day at her school. She sets the scene at a local candy store she would always go to. “Wally’s eyes were focused down, just beyond the edge of the counter, near my waist, and I knew what was coming. A cupped hand smacked my ass. And then he said it. “Best ass in the freshman class Wally. Standing right in your store!” This is troubling to read in multiple ways. I found the harsh language very unnerving to read and is troubling to read in multiple ways. I found the harsh language very unnerving to read and comprehend, making this a scene that was hard for me to read. The main character being sexually harassed is difficult to understand and acknowledge within itself. Seeing Hannah be negatively objectified for her body parts is even more upsetting to read. However, I believe reading about traumatic experiences like Hannah’s is important because of the readers exposure to occurrences that they may not be familiar with. Even though understanding this information is challenging, readers who did not know about sexual assaults before can be offered a glimpse at what they are and how they affect individuals like Hannah. The author chose quotes from Hannah to present disturbance throughout the story.

            Lastly, towards the end of the book, Hannah introduces a class she attended at her school before her suicide. She talks about the class ritual, everyone had a bag where others could drop positive notes into. The teacher had one, where people could drop notes into saying what they wanted to discuss in class.  She explains the class’s significance, and how it was a positive influence in her life until one day where it became a correlation to her death. “In the past, Mrs. Bradley had notes dropped in her bag suggesting group discussions on boyfriends, girlfriends, abortion, family violence, cheating, and tests. No one insisted on knowing who wrote those topics. But for some reason, they refused to have a discussion on suicide without knowing who wrote the note.” This line is most troubling to read when finding out the consequences from Hannah not being able to talk about her thoughts of suicide. After knowing Hannah did commit suicide, it makes the quote all the more troubling. Questions are created as to if the absence of the talk about suicide could’ve factored into her death. It also surfaces ideas as to if Hannah would still be alive if the discussion was held. Relating this back to my own life and opinions, I believe conferences about depression and suicide should be held in schools and communities. From reading about what happened to Hannah, it makes me believe that the attention and help suicidal children need should be mandatory to have in public school systems. Overall, the quote creates many troubling ideas and questions, providing as the authors way to use quotes to express turbulence throughout the story.

            In conclusion, the author, Jay Asher, of “Thirteen Reasons Why” uses quotes throughout the book to illustrate troubling moments and scenes. These quotes make readers reflect and think deeper as to what they really mean and what we can learn from them. This is important because everyone has felt a surge of sorrow in their life at some point, and these quotes can offer a way to cope and deal with these emotions. Reading this book can also spread suicide awareness, creating prevention and allowing discussion about dark topics like suicide to become more accessible. Overall, this book has many scenes that are very difficult to read, and they are best illustrated through quotes the author provides through the main character, Hannah. “Thirteen Reasons Why” is an outstanding story that shows that things may not be how they seem, and ultimately, the beauty in letting go, but never forgetting.